5 Crypto Tax Mistakes That Could Cost You Thousands
Crypto tax season creates anxiety for millions of investors. The rules are complex, the regulations keep evolving, and honest mistakes can lead to serious consequences: IRS audits, substantial penalties, or simply overpaying what you owe.
After analyzing thousands of crypto tax returns and speaking with tax professionals, we’ve identified the five most costly mistakes people make. More importantly, we’ll show you exactly how to avoid them.
Mistake #1: Not Reporting All Transactions
The Problem:
Many crypto users believe they only need to report when they cash out to fiat currency. This is dangerously incorrect.
Every single crypto transaction is potentially taxable, including:
- Trading one cryptocurrency for another (BTC to ETH)
- Using crypto to purchase goods or services
- Receiving airdrops or staking rewards
- Selling NFTs
- Swapping tokens on DEXs
- Providing liquidity to DeFi protocols
The IRS now receives transaction reports from major exchanges through 1099 forms. They know more about your crypto activity than you might think.
The Cost:
The IRS can assess accuracy-related penalties of 20% on top of unpaid taxes. In severe cases involving fraud, penalties can reach 75% plus criminal prosecution.
How to Avoid It:
Use comprehensive tax software that captures all your transactions automatically. Awaken Tax connects directly to your wallets and exchanges, ensuring nothing is missed. With support for 10,000+ DeFi protocols and major NFT marketplaces, it catches transactions that other software overlooks.
The Right Approach:
Connect all your wallets and exchange accounts to tax software. Review the transaction list to ensure everything is captured. Don’t rely on memory or manual tracking.
Mistake #2: Using the Wrong Cost Basis
The Problem:
Cost basis is the original value of your crypto for tax purposes. Get it wrong, and every calculation built on it is wrong.
Common cost basis errors include:
- Ignoring fees: Gas fees and exchange fees should be added to your cost basis
- Wrong acquisition price: Using the wrong date or price
- Not tracking transfers: When you move crypto between wallets, cost basis must follow
- Mixing accounting methods: Inconsistently applying FIFO, LIFO, or HIFO
The Cost:
Incorrect cost basis can result in:
- Overpaying taxes (if you understate cost basis)
- Underpaying taxes (if you overstate cost basis, leading to penalties)
- Audit red flags when your calculations don’t match exchange reports
How to Avoid It:
Choose one accounting method and stick with it consistently:
- FIFO (First In, First Out): Oldest coins are sold first
- LIFO (Last In, First Out): Newest coins are sold first
- HIFO (Highest In, First Out): Highest cost coins are sold first
HIFO typically minimizes taxes in a volatile market, but you must apply it consistently.
Why Awaken Excels:
Awaken Tax tracks cost basis automatically across all your wallets. It correctly handles:
- Transfer tracking between your own wallets
- Gas fee inclusion in cost basis
- Consistent accounting method application
- Rev. Proc. 2024-28 per-wallet cost basis tracking
Mistake #3: Forgetting About DeFi and NFT Activity
The Problem:
DeFi and NFTs create dozens of taxable events that are easy to forget:
DeFi transactions often missed:
- Liquidity pool deposits (may be taxable)
- Yield farming rewards (taxable income)
- Staking rewards (taxable income)
- Token swaps on DEXs (taxable)
- Lending interest received (taxable income)
- Airdrops from protocol usage (taxable income)
NFT transactions often missed:
- Buying NFTs with crypto (triggers gain/loss on the crypto)
- Minting costs as cost basis
- Royalties received (taxable income)
- Failed transactions (gas still affects your position)
The Cost:
The IRS is increasingly focused on DeFi activity. The new CARF (Crypto Asset Reporting Framework) will bring automatic international information sharing in 2026, making it harder to hide unreported activity.
Failure to report can result in:
- Back taxes on all unreported income
- Penalties and interest
- Potential criminal charges for willful evasion
How to Avoid It:
You need tax software that actually understands DeFi and NFT protocols. Most platforms only support a few hundred protocols at best.
Why Awaken Is Different:
Awaken Tax supports over 10,000 DeFi and NFT protocols. This isn’t just about exchange integrations; it’s about understanding what each protocol does and how to categorize transactions correctly.
Whether you’re yield farming on Convex, staking with Lido, trading on Blur, or using bridges between chains, Awaken recognizes and categorizes your activity automatically.
Mistake #4: Not Keeping Adequate Records
The Problem:
If the IRS audits you, the burden of proof is on you. You need to prove:
- When you acquired each asset
- How much you paid
- When you sold
- What you received
Many crypto users have:
- No records of early transactions
- Lost access to old exchange accounts
- No documentation of wallet transfers
- Missing cost basis for gifts or purchases
The Cost:
Without records, the IRS may:
- Assign a zero cost basis (maximum taxable gain)
- Disallow deductions and losses
- Assess negligence penalties
How to Avoid It:
Start keeping comprehensive records now. For future transactions:
- Use tax software that automatically logs everything
- Export transaction history from exchanges regularly
- Document any P2P transactions or gifts
- Keep records of mining/staking setups
For past transactions:
- Gather any records you can find
- Use blockchain explorers to reconstruct history
- Work with a tax professional if needed
How Awaken Helps:
When you connect your wallets to Awaken Tax, your complete on-chain history is captured. Blockchain transactions are permanent, so Awaken can reconstruct your entire history from the first transaction.
For exchange transactions, connect via API or upload CSV files to ensure complete records.
Mistake #5: Using Inadequate Tax Software
The Problem:
Not all crypto tax software is created equal. Many platforms:
- Only support a limited number of exchanges
- Can’t properly categorize DeFi transactions
- Miss NFT marketplaces
- Struggle with cross-chain activity
- Slow down with large transaction volumes
- Miscategorize complex transactions
Using inadequate software leads to errors that you might not even realize until an IRS notice arrives.
Real-World Examples:
- Liquidity pool deposits incorrectly marked as sells
- Staking rewards missed entirely
- Wrong tokens paired in trade calculations
- Bridge transactions treated as income
- Airdrops ignored
The Cost:
Bad software leads to:
- Overpaying taxes due to missed cost basis
- Underpaying taxes due to missed income
- Audit triggers from obvious errors
- Hours wasted manually correcting mistakes
The Solution:
Choose tax software built for modern crypto activity. The right platform should:
- Support thousands of DeFi protocols (not just hundreds)
- Handle NFT transactions correctly
- Work across multiple chains
- Process millions of transactions quickly
- Provide clear categorization you can review
Why Awaken Stands Out:
Awaken Tax was built by crypto natives who understand complex on-chain activity. With:
- 10,000+ supported protocols (more than any competitor)
- Direct multi-chain connections (Ethereum, Solana, Polygon, Arbitrum, and more)
- Enterprise-grade speed (handles millions of transactions)
- Human support from people who understand crypto
- Accuracy guarantee with credits if competitor software was wrong
Most users complete their crypto taxes in under an hour with Awaken.
Bonus: What to Do If You’ve Already Made Mistakes
If you’ve underreported in previous years, don’t panic. You have options:
File an Amended Return
Use Form 1040-X to correct previous years. This shows good faith and may reduce penalties.
Consider Voluntary Disclosure
For significant unreported income, voluntary disclosure programs may provide relief from criminal prosecution.
Get Professional Help
For complex situations, work with a crypto-specialized tax professional or CPA.
Start Fresh This Year
At minimum, get this year right. Use proper software, report everything, and keep good records going forward.
Key Takeaways
- Report everything - Not just fiat cashouts
- Track cost basis properly - Include fees, use consistent methods
- Don’t forget DeFi and NFTs - They’re just as taxable as exchange trading
- Keep records - The burden of proof is on you
- Use adequate software - Built for modern crypto activity
The stakes are too high to get crypto taxes wrong. IRS enforcement is increasing, international information sharing is expanding, and penalties can be severe.
The good news? With the right tools and approach, crypto taxes become manageable. Awaken Tax makes it possible to accurately report even the most complex crypto activity in under an hour.
Ready to get your crypto taxes right? Get started with Awaken Tax free and avoid these costly mistakes.
Compare all crypto tax platforms on our comparison page.